Amy Schumer Lists Iconic Brooklyn Heights Townhouse for $14 Million

Comedian and actress Amy Schumer is parting ways with her historic Brooklyn townhouse, listing the 1829-built property for $14 million. She purchased the Federal-style residence in Brooklyn Heights just two years ago for nearly $12.3 million.

Film buffs will recognize the 4-story home as the Castorini family’s residence in the Oscar-winning 1987 film Moonstruck, starring Cher and Nicolas Cage.

Property Highlights

Price: $14 million
Location: Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn, NY
Size: 5,568 square feet
Bedrooms/Bathrooms: 5 bed, 4 bath
Notable Features: Historic film location, private parking, 30 windows, original fireplaces, restored Federal-style details

Walking Into The Historic Home

Stepping through the double doors of Amy Schumer’s Brooklyn townhouse, you’re immediately transported to another time. The entryway is lined with period details, from the grand pendulum clock to the intricate etched glass panels, that nod to the home’s 19th-century roots.

A curving staircase, backed by blue-and-gold floral wallpaper, draws your eye upward and sets the tone for a home that feels storied but never stuffy.

Practicing Stand-up Comedy in The Parlor Rooms

The two parlors on the main level nod to a bygone era, balanced by subtle modern touches that make the spaces feel warm and lived-in.

The first parlor greets you with a soft velvet loveseat in seafoam green, set beneath a dramatic ceiling medallion and oversized paper lantern light.

Through the wide pocket doors, the second room feels cozier. It features a white sectional curled up around the black marble fireplace, one of eight original mantels in the home, and a wall of tall windows that fill the room with soft, natural light.

Learning to Cook in The Kitchen

The second-floor kitchen pairs farmhouse charm with professional-grade upgrades, which is an ideal setup for Schumer’s husband, a trained chef. At the heart of the space is a marble-topped island surrounded by warm wood cabinetry and a built-in stone pizza oven.

A custom LaCanche range with three ovens takes center stage, paired with a suite of Gaggenau appliances and glass-front cabinets that display every dish within reach.

Just beyond it, a cozy breakfast nook wraps around the bay of windows with custom blue banquette seating and an antique chandelier overhead, making it feel like the kind of spot where coffee turns into conversation.

Feeling Pretty in The Primary Suite

The entire third floor of the townhouse is devoted to the primary suite. It starts with a bedroom that radiates calm with its robin’s-egg blue walls, original marble fireplace, and a trio of oversized windows flooding the space with natural light.

Closet

Through a discreet door, you enter a corridor lined with floor-to-ceiling closets and accented by an ornate green chandelier overhead, which provides an unexpected pop amongst the neutral palette.

En-Suite Bathroom

The en-suite bathroom is straight out of another era, wrapped in floral wallpaper and held together by a glass-and-nickel shower enclosure at its center.

Dual pedestal sinks rest beneath twin mirrors and delicate light sconces, while a vintage dresser provides extra storage space.

However, it’s the perfectly weathered freestanding marble tub sitting beside its own fireplace that really ties the room together for a feeling of cozy, old-world elegance.

Guest Bedrooms That Aren’t a Trainwreck

On the 4th and final floor, the guest bedrooms are full of charm and character, each one telling a story of its own.

One is dressed in a whimsical bird-and-branch wallpaper, with a carved marble fireplace and light wood floors that glow beneath natural light from two tall bookshelf windows.

Another guest room takes on a more refined, earthy tone with grasscloth walls and a tailored, low-profile wood bed. A plush pink velvet chaise softens the space, sitting between another original fireplace and a bookshelf.

Snatched Interior Amenities

The home continues its feeling of warm vintage luxury with thoughtful amenities that reflect both comfort and creativity.

Home Office

Tucked behind black-framed windows and grounded by rich wood accents, the home office feels intimate and purposeful, made for focused work or quiet sketching at the vintage drafting desk beneath a delicate chandelier.

Home Gym

Down in the gym, exposed stone walls and warm plywood ceilings meet functional equipment and mood-lifting string lights—an unexpected but effective combination that makes the workout space feel energizing, not sterile.

Library

Finally, the library—wrapped in custom built-ins and dressed in rustic beams—offers a cozy escape, complete with a velvet couch, curated shelves, and a fireplace that makes the room feel like the heart of a storybook.

Backyard

Outside, a private balcony sets the scene for morning coffee or late-night conversations, with an iron railing that frames views of the lush backyard.

Below, the yard unfolds into a kid-friendly play area wrapped in artificial turf, dotted with cheerful yellow chairs and a mini climbing wall. Framed by tall trees and brick walls, it’s a rare patch of greenery in Brooklyn—equal parts playground and grown-up hideout.

Final Thoughts

Amy Schumer’s decision to list her Brooklyn Heights townhouse for $14 million signals a return to her roots on the Upper West Side—but it also opens the door to something rare.

The historic property, with its cinematic charm and architectural pedigree, is more than just a home; it’s a piece of New York’s cultural fabric.

As Schumer moves back uptown, the townhouse is now poised for its next chapter—offering one lucky buyer the chance to own a true icon in one of the city’s most storied neighborhoods.