Derek Jeter Sells His Tiedemann Castle For $6.3 Million

Derek Jeter, the legendary New York Yankees shortstop and Hall of Famer, has finally sold his historic Tiedemann Castle for $6.3 million.

This remarkable property, situated on the picturesque shores of Greenwood Lake in New York, has been a significant part of Jeter’s life and is steeped in history. Let’s take an exclusive look at Tiedemann Castle, its unique features, and the story behind its sale.

A Historic Estate on Greenwood Lake

Tiedemann Castle is located on the edge of Greenwood Lake, a scenic body of water that spans the border between New York and New Jersey. The castle, which dates back to the early 1900s, is one of the most distinctive properties in the area.

The estate sits on 4 acres of land, offering breathtaking views of the lake and the surrounding hills, making it a serene retreat away from the hustle and bustle of city life. Built in the early 1900s by New York doctor Rudolph Gudewill, Tiedemann Castle boasts a history as rich as its architecture.

Photos by Stephen Dolinsky

In 1952, John and Julia Tiedemann, along with their 13 children, including their adopted son William Connors (Derek Jeter’s maternal grandfather), transformed the estate into a large family home. The Tiedemann’s parted with the estate in 1996, which Jeter went back to purchase when it hit the market in 2002 for $1.2 million.

Jeter then embarked on a massive restoration project and tried to sell the home for upwards of $14 million over the last year before cutting the price on an expedited sale.

A Closer Look At The Historic Castle

Tiedemann Castle is not just a luxurious residence; it’s a piece of history. The property’s unique architecture and design elements reflect the grandeur of early 20th-century craftsmanship.

Gothic Revival Architecture

The castle is built in the Gothic Revival style, characterized by its steeply pitched roofs, pointed arches, and intricate stonework.

Photos by Stephen Dolinsky

The exterior features stunning stone facades, turrets, and battlements, giving the property the appearance of a medieval castle. This architectural style is rare in the United States, making Tiedemann Castle a unique and historically significant property.

Photos by Stephen Dolinsky

Main Residence

The main residence spans approximately 12,500 square feet, offering a blend of old-world charm and modern amenities. The interior features include high, beamed ceilings, original wood paneling, and large stone fireplaces that add to the castle’s rustic yet elegant ambiance.

Photos by Stephen Dolinsky

The layout includes multiple living spaces, formal dining rooms, and sitting areas, each designed to offer comfort while preserving the castle’s historic character.

Photos by Stephen Dolinsky

Seven Bedrooms and Nine Bathrooms

The castle includes seven bedrooms and nine bathrooms, providing ample space for family and guests.

Photos by Stephen Dolinsky

Each bedroom is unique, with features such as custom woodwork, lake views, and access to private terraces or balconies.

Photos by Stephen Dolinsky

The bathrooms have been updated with modern fixtures, ensuring that the historic home also meets contemporary standards of luxury.

Photos by Stephen Dolinsky

Private Lakefront and Boathouse

Photos by Stephen Dolinsky


One of the standout features of Tiedemann Castle is its private lakefront access. The property includes a boathouse, which allows for easy access to the lake, perfect for boating, fishing, and other water activities.

The lakefront offers stunning views of Greenwood Lake, creating a peaceful and private setting for relaxation and recreation.

Pool and Gardens

Photos by Stephen Dolinsky

The estate also features a large outdoor swimming pool, surrounded by beautifully landscaped gardens and a pristine view of the lake. The outdoor spaces are ideal for entertaining, with plenty of room for hosting events or simply enjoying the natural beauty of the surroundings.

Renovations and Updates

Photos by Stephen Dolinsky

Since purchasing the property, Jeter invested significantly in renovations and updates to both the interior and exterior of the castle. These updates were carefully done to maintain the historic integrity of the property while incorporating modern conveniences and luxury finishes.

The Sale of Tiedemann Castle

After several years on and off the market, Derek Jeter finally sold Tiedemann Castle for $6.3 million. The sale marks the end of an era for Jeter, as the property held deep personal significance. The estate was not just a home, but a family heirloom that connected Jeter to his roots and provided a retreat from his high-profile career in Major League Baseball.

The decision to sell Tiedemann Castle was likely influenced by Jeter’s growing commitments in other areas, including his ownership role with the Miami Marlins and his focus on other business ventures. While the sale might be bittersweet, it also opens a new chapter for the historic estate and its next owner.

Author

  • Evan is a seasoned real estate agent with over seven years of experience in Los Angeles’ luxury real estate market. As founder of Homes of Celebs, Evan's passion for luxury homes and dedication to uncovering the stories behind the hottest listings inspired the creation of this platform. Evan is a licensed agent representing Coldwell Banker and specializes in sell-side transactions.

    View all posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *