Hurley Haywood Sells Florida Home For $4.75 Million
Legendary race car driver Hurley Haywood has officially sold his custom Florida waterfront home for $4.75 million after listing it only a few months ago for $5.2 million.
Haywood, who retired to Florida more than a decade ago, purchased the St. Augustine property in 2012 for $725,000 before undertaking a full custom rebuild, transforming it into a refined coastal compound that blends durability, privacy, and charm.
Designed by Cronk Duch Architects, the home reflects the same precision and attention to detail that defined Haywood’s Hall of Fame racing career.
Property Highlights
Price: $4.75 million
Location: St. Augustine, Florida
Size: 4,180 square feet
Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 5
Notable Features: Two private casitas, waterfront dock with boat and jet ski lifts, heated saltwater lap pool, residential elevator, home theater, whole-home generator, built-in safe, two new AC units
For more information about this sale, reach out to listing agents Jane Chefan at 904-463-117 or Jessica Chefan Hansen at 904-200-8855 of One Sotheby’s International Realty.
Entering Haywood’s Florida Home
The entrance to Hurley Haywood’s home begins through a narrow courtyard passage lined with smooth stucco walls and tropical plants, where travertine steps lead up to an arched wooden front door framed in dark trim.
Potted palms frame the entry, softening the architectural lines and creating a layered transition from exterior to interior before reaching the glass-paneled door.
Stepping inside, the foyer opens upward with tall white paneled walls and a staircase rising along the left side, finished with dark handrails and light wood treads.
The arched front door repeats the curve seen outside, bringing natural light through its divided glass panes, while brass wall sconces and a simple tiled floor keep the space balanced between classic detailing and coastal design.
Open Kitchen
Just beyond the foyer, the home opens directly into the kitchen.
In the center, a large island is finished in rich wood cabinetry and topped with a thick slab of marble, with bar seating tucked beneath an extended wood counter that creates a layered work-and-dining surface.
Above, oversized black pendant lights hang in alignment over the island, drawing the eye upward to the paneled ceiling and recessed lighting.
Along the perimeter, white and mirrored cabinetry frames a professional-grade range and stone backsplash, while integrated high-end appliances are built into the millwork.
Dark wide-plank heart-of-pine floors contrast against the lighter cabinetry, reinforcing the balance between classic detailing and modern design.
Dining Area
The kitchen transitions directly into the dining area, where a round dining table sits centered on a large rug beneath a suspended light fixture, framed by tall windows and glass doors that open toward greenery and the pool.
Wet Bar
Just off the dining area, a built-in wet bar is tucked into its own alcove, wrapped in custom wood cabinetry that mirrors the island’s finish.
Open shelving displays glassware above a stone countertop, while a glass-front 140-bottle Sub-Zero wine cooler is integrated into the millwork.
Living Room
Beyond the dining area, the layout opens fully into the living room, completing the home’s main entertaining spaces.
A coffered ceiling with recessed lighting stretches overhead, while a central fireplace with detailed white millwork anchors the far wall, framed by round windows that bring in filtered light.
Seating is arranged around a large square coffee table, with upholstered armchairs, a tailored sofa, and deep blue lounge chairs creating a balanced conversation layout.
Along the exterior wall, a series of glass-paneled doors stretches across the room, opening to the surrounding greenery and water views.
Home Theater
Tucked away from the main living areas, the home theater is designed as a fully enclosed viewing space with deep green walls and recessed ceiling lighting that keeps the focus on the screen.
A large sectional wraps around the room, layered with textured throws and pillows, all centered around a low round table.
Dark curtains frame the windows, allowing the room to be dimmed for movie nights, while a wide console sits beneath a projector screen.
Primary Suite
Upstairs, the primary suite unfolds as a sequence of connected spaces, each facing toward the surrounding water and greenery while maintaining a clear, organized layout.
Bedroom
The bedroom centers on a low-profile bed framed by a dark paneled headboard wall, with matching nightstands and brass reading lamps on either side.
Above, a tray ceiling with recessed lighting and a ceiling fan mirrors the home’s clean millwork, while artwork adds contrast against the white walls.
The room extends forward into a dedicated lounge area set within a window-lined alcove, where two patterned armchairs face outward toward the water.
Private Balcony
Just beyond the lounge, a private covered balcony opens to sweeping views of the bay and surrounding mangroves.
The porch ceiling and railings are finished in crisp white, with a hanging bench and armchairs gathered together.
En-Suite Bathroom
The en-suite bathroom continues the suite, beginning with a freestanding soaking tub placed directly beneath a row of large windows.
Marble countertops line both sides of the room, paired with dark wood vanities and polished hardware.
A glass-enclosed shower with marble tile sits further down the space, maintaining clear sightlines and consistent finishes throughout.
Walk-in Closet
Finally, the walk-in closet functions as its own dressing room, fitted with dark wood dressers, louvered doors, and built-in storage lining both sides.
A striped runner leads down the center toward a seating nook at the far end, where a single upholstered chair sits beneath shuttered windows.
Guest Casitas
Set apart from the main residence, the two guest casitas each have their own unique design, offering visitors privacy and a future buyer flexibility.
Coastal Blue Bedroom
The first casita bedroom has a crisp coastal palette, with a king bed dressed in white bedding, blue accent pillows, and a striped blue-and-cream area rug underfoot.
White plantation shutters and clean-lined walls keep the space bright, while colorful contemporary artwork adds contrast above the bed.
Global Canopy Suite
The second casita takes on a more layered, collected aesthetic, centered around a four-poster canopy bed with turned wood posts and a patterned textile draped across the foot.
A vaulted wood-paneled ceiling draws the eye upward, complementing the darker hardwood floors and antique-style furniture.
Outdoor Spaces
The outdoor spaces extend the home’s living areas into a layered waterfront setting, combining covered lounging areas, recreational amenities, and direct water access.
Covered Deck
Just beyond the living room, a covered deck with a soft blue beadboard ceiling offers a shaded place to relax with cushioned lounge seating and side tables.
Framed by lush tropical landscaping and open views toward the water, it functions as an outdoor sitting room with direct sightlines to the surrounding marsh and bay.
Heated Saltwater Lap Pool
Running parallel to the house, the heated saltwater lap pool is designed with clean lines and a raised wall featuring water spouts that spill into the narrow basin.
Surrounded by pavers and dense greenery, the pool area feels private while still connected to the main house.
Sauna
Tucked within the landscaping, a barrel-style sauna adds a dedicated wellness element to the property on an elevated wood platform.
Private Dock
Lastly, the dock stretches into the calm waterway and is built with concrete pilings and a vinyl bulkhead for durability.
It features both boat and jet ski lifts, offering immediate access to the open water while maintaining a sturdy, low-maintenance shoreline structure.
Why is Haywood Selling?
The custom-built residence, with its expansive outdoor amenities and multiple living spaces, represents a lifestyle rooted in entertaining and coastal living at scale.
However, with Haywood now 77, it’s reasonable to speculate that selling his St. Augustine waterfront home may reflect a desire to simplify and transition into a property that requires less upkeep.
For its new owner, it offers not only prime waterfront access but a thoughtfully designed home that fully captures the appeal of Florida’s Intracoastal setting.
