Penn Badgley’s Former $1.9 Million Brooklyn Apartment

You and Gossip Girl star Penn Badgley and his wife, singer Domino Kirke, lived in this charming Brooklyn co-op for 3 years before selling it for $1.9 million in May 2024. Badgley and Kirke originally purchased the three-bedroom, two-bath apartment for $1.8 million in 2021.

Built in 1931, the prewar Art Deco residence sits just a block from Prospect Park in one of Brooklyn’s most coveted neighborhoods and served as the place where they began their family.

Property Highlights

Price: $1.9 million
Location: Brooklyn, New York
Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 2
Notable Features: Updated kitchen, art deco architecture, proximity to Prospect Park

Open-Concept Layout Without a Hidden Glass Cage

Walking into Penn Badgley’s former Brooklyn apartment, you’ll first find the open-concept living and dining area illuminated by a wall of windows that flood the space with natural light.

At the front of the room, built-in booth seating lined with playful cushions pairs with two wooden chairs to frame a cozy dining nook, centered around a sleek round table beneath a woven pendant light.

The living area extends into the rest of the room, grounded by graphic rugs and a deep, low-profile sectional placed in front of arched wall niches that act as curated art and book displays.

Beware of The Kitchen Knives

Around the corner, the kitchen had been completely remodeled to fit Badgley and Kirke’s personal style, starting with painted cabinetry in a soft, sea-glass blue that fills the galley layout beside stainless steel appliances, complemented by richly veined stone countertops.

A backsplash of glossy emerald green tiles adds a jolt of color and texture, catching light throughout the day, while brass fixtures offer an unexpected, elegant contrast.

Primary Suite For Hiding an Evidence Shoebox

Down the hall, the primary suite’s bedroom is colorful and eclectic, with soft peach walls, parquet floors, and oversized windows that flood the room with natural light.

The room is filled with vibrant design choices from the royal blue curtains framing views of the treetops to the pink bedding, adding a cozy touch.

En-Suite Bathroom

Attached to the bedroom is a windowed en-suite bathroom that has been stylishly updated with modern finishes while preserving its classic aesthetic. Crisp white subway tiles line the walls, accented with a thin band of mosaic tile for a subtle graphic touch.

The tiles extend around the glass-enclosed shower with a waterfall showerhead and pedestal sink completing the space with a functional yet minimalistic design that feels both fresh and timeless.

Cassius’s Room

Across from the primary suite, the kids’ bedroom features a bold, sky-blue bookcase that takes up one wall, offering plenty of storage for books, toys, and a growing sneaker collection.

On the opposite side, a simple upholstered headboard and understated bedding keep the focus on vibrant personal touches, like framed basketball memorabilia and colorful jerseys.

Natural light pours in through windows dressed with soft, gathered Roman shades, brightening the striped multicolor rug below that adds a youthful energy to the room’s clean, laid-back aesthetic.

Guest Bathroom For Washing Off The Blood

Just steps away, the guest bathroom is wrapped in warm, neutral-toned tiles that extend across the walls and floor, accented by a delicate scrollwork border that adds subtle texture without overwhelming the space.

A pedestal sink and chrome fixtures lend a timeless appeal, while a sleek glass shower enclosure and rainfall showerhead bring a modern feel to the traditional footprint.

Final Thoughts

Penn Badgley’s former $1.9 million Brooklyn apartment served as a charming and intimate space for their growing family.

But with two children already, one biological son and one stepson, and the exciting news that they’re expecting twins in the summer of 2025, the pre-war corner unit had served its purpose before needing to move on to something bigger.

As Badgley closes out another major chapter with the release of You’s final season, the sale of their Brooklyn home is just one piece of a larger moment of transition, making space for both a busier household and the next phase of his career.