‘Sopranos’ Writers List Historic Shelter Island Estate For $6.5 Million

Emmy Award-winning writer-producers Robin Green and Mitchell Burgess have listed their historic Shelter Island estate for $6.5 million.

The couple, best known for their work on ‘The Sopranos’ and as creators of ‘Blue Bloods’, purchased the property in 2020 for $2.8 million after finding portions of the estate in significant disrepair.

Over the past few years, they carefully restored and updated the property while preserving the character that had long made it a gathering place for artists, writers, and cultural figures.

Originally built in the 1880s, the estate now blends historic architecture with extensive modern improvements.

Property Highlights

Price: $6.5 Million
Location: Shelter Island, New York
Size: 3,863 square feet
Lot Size: 2 acres
Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 6
Notable Features: 1888 Victorian residence, saltwater pool, pool house, artist studio, landscaped gardens, mature orchards, screened porch, butler’s pantry, private balcony

For more information about this listing, reach out to the listing agent, Stacey Cohen, at stacey.cohen@theagencyre.com.

Entering The Historic Estate

Originally constructed in 1888, the historic estate reveals itself gradually at the end of a private road, where gates open to a property shaped by more than a century of history and carefully maintained grounds.

Mature trees frame the approach, while gardens designed by landscape architect Jeff Mendoza create a sense of order and symmetry.

The walk to the front entrance begins along a gravel pathway lined with clipped boxwood hedges and geometric garden beds.

Closer to the home, a central fountain sits within a courtyard garden framed by sculpted hedges, while a pergola draped in cascading wisteria connects the main house to the barn.

Living Room

Stepping into the living room of the main house, the home opens into a series of inviting gathering spaces designed by Heiberg Cummings.

One seating area is arranged around a substantial stone fireplace set within a window-lined alcove.

Surrounded by oversized sofas and armchairs, the space is designed for conversation, with views extending through multiple windows toward the landscaping outside.

Across the room, a second sitting area is positioned beside large French doors and windows overlooking the property’s gardens.

When opened, the doors offer direct access to the courtyard, allowing the greenery, fountain, and flowers to become part of the living space.

Dining Area

Directly down the hallway, the dining area begins with a wood dining table positioned beneath a traditional chandelier, providing space for everyday dining and larger dinner parties.

Directly behind it, a built-in window seat wraps around a small table, bringing natural light into the room and creating a casual spot to linger before or after meals.

Kitchen

A few steps beyond the dining area, the kitchen features white custom cabinetry, glass-front upper cabinets, open display shelving, and polished stone countertops.

At the center of the room, a marble-topped island provides additional prep space and casual seating beneath a vintage-inspired pendant light.

Professional-grade appliances, including a range and oversized refrigerator, are integrated into the cabinetry.

Covered Porch

Just off the main living spaces, a screened and covered porch extends the home’s connection to the surrounding grounds while protecting it from the elements.

At one end, a lounge with woven sofas and cushioned seating creates a comfortable place for conversation or quiet afternoons, while a dining table is placed at the opposite side of the porch.

Primary Suite

Upstairs, the primary suite occupies a private corner of the home, combining generous proportions with views across the surrounding gardens and orchards.

The bedroom starts the suite off with soft neutral finishes lining the bed next to a small curved alcove set up as a reading nook.

Sitting Room

Just beyond the sleeping area is a bright sitting room tucked beneath the vaulted ceiling. A distinctive round window serves as the focal point of the space, framing views of the property’s landscaping while bringing in natural light throughout the day.

Private Balcony

French doors open from the suite onto a private balcony overlooking the grounds while accommodating lounge seating for a natural spot to enjoy the scenery from above.

En-Suite Bathroom

The en-suite bathroom continues the home’s classic design with white millwork, marble surfaces, and traditional fixtures.

A marble-topped vanity sits opposite a freestanding clawfoot soaking tub, while additional marble detailing wraps the lower walls and flooring.

Art Studio

Tucked beneath a vaulted ceiling inside the barn, the home’s art studio provides a flexible creative space removed from the more formal gathering areas.

White-painted floors and walls create a clean backdrop, while windows on multiple sides bring in natural light and views of the surrounding greenery.

Saltwater Pool

Beyond the gardens, the outdoor amenities center around a 60-foot saltwater pool framed by stone pathways, manicured hedges, and mature landscaping.

Positioned alongside the rectangular pool is a covered cabana set up as an outdoor living room open on multiple sides and finished with draped curtains.

Pool House

Right behind the pool area, a separate pool house adds a fully self-contained guest retreat.

The structure features its own living area beneath a skylight, with French doors opening directly to the surrounding gardens and pool terrace.

A compact kitchen and dining area provide everyday convenience, while a private bedroom and full bathroom allow guests to stay comfortably and independently from the main residence.

Final Thoughts

Green and Burgess acquired this estate as an ambitious restoration project, taking on a property that had fallen into disrepair and spending the next several years carefully returning it to its former glory.

Now, with much of that work complete, the couple is looking to pass the home on to a new owner, ensuring that its connection to Shelter Island’s creative legacy remains intact.

For that future buyer, the property offers thoughtful renovations and resort-style amenities on one of Shelter Island’s most desirable stretches of land, all within minutes of beaches, marinas, and the island’s village centers.